Abacus: Small Enough to Jail
May 16, 2017. Last October I wrote an article about
“Abacus: Small Enough to Jail,” a documentary which was
shown as part of the New York Film Festival. While I
realize most readers might not have been able to
make it to the festival, how fortunate it is that this
excellent documentary will start a run at IFC Center
on Friday, May 19.
Theatrical releases can be challenging for
documentaries. The typical moviegoer may not
think of a documentary as being as gripping or
interesting as a main stream film. In the case of
“Abacus: Small Enought to Jail,” how wrong that
reasoning would be.
“Abacus: Small Enough to Jail” is a gripping
account of the, under reported, trial of the Abacus
Federal Savings Bank, the only bank to have faced
criminal charges in the wake of the 2008 financial
crises. Even though much bigger banks participated
in deliberate and massive mortgage fraud, no criminal
indictments were every brought against them. They
were bailed out by the tax payers because they were
deemed “too big to fail.” In other words, had they
failed they would have wreaked havoc on the U.S.
economy. So, they got a pass. Abacus, as the film’s
title suggests, was small enough to pick on, and was
singled out for prosecution, as the proxy for the much bigger
banking corruption that was not, and apparently could not, be
punished.
The Abacus Federal Savings Bank was a
relatively small community bank, located in New York
City’s Chinatown. The bank was started by Thomas
Sung as a way to offer loans and mortgages to
Chinese immigrants. The bigger banks would gladly
take deposits from immigrants, but would not give
them loans.
Sung is presented as a modern day George
Bailey (from the 1946 film, “It’s a Wonderful Life” )
committed to helping his community. Due to some
corrupt Abacus loan officers, who the bank caught,
fired and turned in to the authorities, Sung’s business and
reputation were put on the line. However, the
prosecution did not count on Sung’s three tenacious
daughters.
Director Steve James, producer Mark Mitten,
cinematographer Tom Bergman, editors John
Farbrother and David E. Simpson have fashioned an
incredible story which did not receive much media
attention while it was happening. A challenge faced
by the filmmakers was that their cameras were not
allowed in the court room during the trial. As a result,
they have come up with clever, interesting and
creative juxtapositions of visual and aural elements
which bring the trial to life and, I think, are just as
effective, and maybe even more effective, than
showing the trial itself.
What has to taken into account here is something
which I bring up repeatedly in one of the college
classes that I teach, “Mass Communication and
Popular Culture.” I tell my students that there is no
such thing as objectivity in documentaries. Every
documentary has a point of view, and there is nothing
wrong with that. I also tell them that great
documentaries have to have great characters, as do
fiction films. Clearly, “Abacus: Small Enough to Jail” is
told from the point of view of the Sung family and is
very sympathetic to them. While this
is certainly a story with great characters who take on
the “powers that be,” director James, much to his
credit, has also had the objectivity to interview and
present the points of view of New York District
Attorney Cyrus Vance, Jr., his prosecution team and
two of the jurors who struggled to reach a verdict.
Abacus: Small Enough to Jail” is an iconic story.
It is one that we like and with which we are
comfortable, about the little guy taking on larger
forces. Ultimately though, it is a thought provoking
story about community, culture, family, honor,
immigrants and relentless government prosecution
that is truly riveting, heart felt and frightening.
IFC Center is located at 323 Sixth Avenue. Visit
www.ifccenter.com for more information.
Posted on May 16, 2017, in Documentary, Uncategorized and tagged Abacus Federal Savings Bank, Abacus: Small Enough to Jail, Cyrus Vance Jr., David E. Simpson, George Bailey, IFC Center, It's a Wonderful Life, John Farbrother, Mark Mitten, Steve James, Thomas Sung, Tom Bergman. Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.
Leave a comment
Comments 0